How do you measure quality in education?

How do you measure quality in education?

Posted by Elizabeth Cudney on May 3, 2019 11:49 am

I am curious to hear what metrics are used to measure quality in education and why you think it is a good metric.

Re: How do you measure quality in education?

Posted by Cindy Veenstra on May 14, 2019 7:53 pm

For our colleges and universities, I prefer to think of quality in education in terms of the graduation rate. A high graduation rate means a high percent of the entering freshmen succeeded in achieving their goals for their degree. There is much variability in the graduation rate among colleges. Colleges that provide a student success (quality) culture, tutoring and mentoring and a high level of student support, tend to have higher graduation rates. If students are relatively happy in their first year because of the support they are getting, even if the curriculum is difficult for them, they will tend to return to the same college and graduate, especially if financial aid is available if they need it.

Another metric that is becoming very relevant for quality in education is the graduate placement rate (what percent of the graduates were able to find their first post-college job in their field of study?)  Obviously after spending 4 or 5 years on a degree, a graduate wants to find a job in the field he/she studied. To achieve a high graduate placement rate, a college usually has a partnership with its career center. One way career centers help is by encouraging students to experience an internship in their field while they are in college; employers look for that kind of experience. 

Cindy Veenstra

Re: How do you measure quality in education?

Posted by Jim Bennett on May 29, 2019 12:01 pm

For our school division, our main metric we focus on is graduation rate, coupled with a secondary metric of First Nations-Metis-Indiginous graduation rates.

We recently started creating a metrics map for our school division, encompassing the various business units we have.  This is still very much a work in progress, but I'll list it here to give an idea of where we are headed:
 
Satellite Metrics (Board of Education)
Metric Description Feeds Metric(s)
B-1 Celebrate & Promote Catholic Identity  
B-2 Improve Student Learning & Achievement  
B-3 Build Relationships & Partnerships  
B-4 Promote Stewardship  
 
30000 Foot Metrics (Learning/Student Services, Division Administration)
Metric Description Feeds Metric(s)
L-1 Improving First Nations and Métis Student Engagement and Graduation Rates and Following Their Voices B-2, B-3
L-2 Reading, Writing, Math at Grade Level and Saskatchewan Reads B-2
L-3 Graduation Rates B-2
L-4 Operational Spending B-4
L-5 Early Years B-2
L-6 Catholic Education B-1, B-2
 
Technology 10000 Foot Metrics (Department)
Metric Description Feeds Metric(s)
T-1 Support Request Average-Time-To-Close (ATTC) B-2, B-4, L-1->L6
T-2 Tier 3 Team Velocity B-2, B-4, L-1->L6
T-3 Data Team Velocity (Request completion time) B-2, B-4, L-1->L6
T-4 Applied Technology Average-Time-To-Close (ATTC) B-2, B-4, L-1->L7
T-5 Operational Spending B-4, L-4
T-6 Client Satisfaction B-3, B-4, L1->L6
     
Financial Services 10000 Foot Metrics (Department)
Metric Description Feeds Metric(s)
F-1 Client Satisfaction (employees, parents, vendors, customers) B-3, B-4
F-2 Response Times B-3, B-4
F-3 Accuracy of Data Entry B-3, B-4, L-4
F-4 Operational Spending B-4, L-4

We are launching a K-12 Network here, where we will be discussing topics like this.  Perhaps you'd be interested in joining our network to take part in our monthly calls and discussions?  We will also be posting information to a MyASQ blog and this discussion board.